Read This Someday

Home for Thanksgiving: Who Are You Now?

The first Thanksgiving home from college has a strange problem built into it: two people are walking toward the same front door, and each is picturing someone different. You’re picturing an adult who runs their own days. Your parents are picturing the kid who left in August. Both pictures are partly right.

Arizona State’s dean of students, Nicole Taylor, made this exact point in ASU News’ coverage of freshmen coming home for Thanksgiving: the adjustment may be bigger than it looks, because the student changed and so did the parents. Thanksgiving is about ten days out. That’s enough time to fix most of it, and it takes one phone call.

The short version

What’s trueWhat to do about it
You expect adult treatment. Your parents expect the person who left.Name the gap out loud before you travel instead of discovering it at 11 p.m. over a curfew.
Unspoken rules cause most of the fights.Settle sleep, car, check-ins, chores, and friend time ahead of time.
The break is a few days.Treat arguing over small things as a cost to avoid, not a point to win.
Both sides have changed.Go in curious, not defensive. Flexibility beats being right.

What is the best way to prepare for your first Thanksgiving home?

Talk about the break before you travel. That’s the whole answer, and the steps are short:

  1. Call your parents this week. Not a text. A call, ten minutes, no agenda except “let’s plan the break.”
  2. Ask what they’re expecting. Family dinners, the Friday relatives, church, a chore or two. Find out the real list, not the one you’re imagining.
  3. Say what you’re expecting. Sleep schedule, time with friends, the car, how much you’ll be out.
  4. Agree on check-ins. A text when you’re heading somewhere and a text when you’re home safe. That’s it.
  5. Pick your friend nights. Name them, so neither side is guessing.
  6. Decide what flexes. If plans shift, how will you tell each other?

Dean Taylor says the same thing. Communicate early, because “if everyone’s expectations are clear, there’s less room for confusion or hurt feelings.” She also suggests parents approach the student “from the perspective of two adults talking to each other.” That works in both directions. If you want to be spoken to like an adult, make the call like one.

I’ll add what I wish every kid heard before their first break: calling ahead is not asking permission. It’s the opposite. It’s the most adult thing you can do in that house, because it shows you’ve thought about how your choices land on other people.

Why it gets tense (and why it’s nobody’s fault)

You’ve spent three months with nobody asking where you were at 1 a.m. Nobody noticed when you slept until noon, ate cereal for dinner, or came back after the sun rose. You got used to it fast. Most people do.

Your parents, meanwhile, spent eighteen years as the people who knew where you were. They don’t switch that off because you moved into a dorm. Worry doesn’t take a semester off. When you walk in and head out again at 10 p.m. without a word, they aren’t trying to control you. They’re doing what they’ve done your whole life, and the habit hasn’t caught up with the facts.

Dr. Lisa Farkas, a licensed psychologist at Rowan University, framed it well in Newswise’s “Welcome Home. Who Are You?”. She calls a child’s growing independence “just another developmental milestone,” and says communication, consideration, and compromise are the keys to getting through it. Notice that two of those three words are about the other person.

Curfew, check-ins, and the car

This is where most first-break fights actually happen.

Curfew. Farkas says a curfew at 18 is probably unnecessary, but asking where you’ll be is reasonable, since different environments call for different behavior. Dean Taylor’s version is a question parents can ask: “Does the old curfew still apply?” Both are saying the same thing. The old rule is up for discussion. It isn’t automatically dead, and it isn’t automatically alive.

My take: you don’t need a time. You need a way for your parents to sleep. If you’ll be out late, tell them roughly when you expect to be home, and text if that changes. A curfew is a number. A check-in is information. Parents who get information rarely care about the number.

The car. Whose car, how often, who’s driving home after dinner at a friend’s house. Settle it before you land. If your parents want a hard stop on the car, that’s usually the real fear behind the curfew question, and it’s a smaller ask than a rule about you.

Drinking. Be honest with yourself here. If you’ve been drinking on campus, you’re going home to people who may not know that, and who are legally and emotionally invested in what you do under their roof. Don’t pretend the topic doesn’t exist, and don’t ambush them with it at the dinner table. Ask what their expectation is. You can disagree with the answer. You can’t negotiate a rule nobody said out loud. If friends are driving, decide that ahead of time too, and have a ride plan that doesn’t depend on anyone’s good judgment at midnight.

Time with high school friends

You’ll want to see them. Everyone does. This is the first time in months you can sit in a car with people who knew you at fifteen, and it matters.

Your family wants time with you too, and they’ve been counting on it. Both are legitimate. Dean Taylor lists “how much time will be dedicated to catching up with high school friends?” as a question families should talk through, and I agree with putting it on the table early.

A workable split: show up fully for the meals, the cooking, the relatives, the Thursday. Then claim your friend nights without apology. Say which nights before you go, not the afternoon of. If a friend group wants every evening, you’re allowed to say no to one of them. Farkas suggests letting the student choose some family activities and explaining why the important ones matter. Take that seriously on both ends. If your parents say the Friday dinner matters, believe them. If you need Saturday night out, say so.

One more thing, and it stings a little: your friends may have changed, and so may you. The easy nights you remember might feel stiffer. That’s normal. It doesn’t mean something’s wrong with your friendships. It means you’ve been living somewhere else.

What your parents are probably wondering

You’re not the only one nervous. Your parents have been guessing at how you’re doing from short texts and the occasional photo. They want to know if you’re okay. They also want to hear about your classes, your friends, and your life, and they don’t know how to ask without sounding like they’re prying.

Dean Taylor’s tip is to ask open-ended, curious questions rather than interrogations, and to have those conversations during everyday activities, like cooking or driving. It works for students too. Share some of what’s going on without feeling you must report everything. Tell them about the class you like. Tell them about the friend you made. Keep what’s private private, and don’t treat every question as an audit.

If you’re struggling, home is a good place to say so. If your fall has been rough, the Red Zone stretch is wrapping up for first-years about now, and a parent across the table may be the first person who gets to hear it. Don’t wait for the perfect moment. Kitchen counters are good enough.

Money questions may come up too. If your parents are helping pay, a few questions about spending, grades, or next semester are fair game. What it actually costs your parents to support you is worth reading before you sit down. And if the idea of leaving school is quietly on your mind, the numbers in why quitting college mid-year costs so much are better looked at together than alone.

It’s only a few days

Here’s the part nobody wants to hear on day two: it’s a short visit. A few days. You can win a fight about curfew and spend the rest of the break in a cold house. Or you can let a small thing go and have a good Thanksgiving.

Pick the hill. Most things aren’t it. Stay flexible, and expect your parents to wobble too, because they’re learning a new version of you at the same speed you’re learning a new version of home.

This isn’t the same conversation as moving back for good. If someday you do end up under that roof for longer, living at home in your 20s is a different arrangement with real rules, a savings target, and an end date. A holiday weekend doesn’t need a contract. It needs a decent talk and a little grace.

If you’re still sorting out what this whole first year is for, what the summer before college is actually for is a good reminder that you were never meant to arrive finished. Growing up shows up first at the dinner table, and this is where you practice it. More on that in the college and beyond section.

What to do this week

  • Call home before you book the ride. Ten minutes. Ask what they’re picturing. Tell them what you’re picturing.
  • Write down three agreements: how you’ll check in, when you’ll be out, and who’s driving.
  • Choose your friend nights and tell your family before you arrive.
  • Plan one thing just for them. Cook something. Do the dishes without being asked. Sit through the old movie.
  • Hold your temper on day two. That’s when the old patterns tend to show up.

You left as a kid and you’re coming home as someone else. Let them meet that person slowly, and be patient while they do.

This article is part of the College & Beyond collection.

Browse all College & Beyond lessons →