Read This Someday

Why Social Media Age Bans Aren't Working

Australia banned social media for anyone under 16 back in December 2025. It was supposed to be the law that finally did what parents couldn’t — pull an entire generation off these platforms by force of government. Eleven months in, an analysis published October 16, 2026 in The Conversation lays out the actual numbers, and they’re not close. Seven in ten kids who had accounts on the newly restricted platforms still have them. More than 80% of Australian 10-to-15-year-olds are still using social media frequently. The ban didn’t fail quietly. It failed in public, with the data to prove it.

The short version

What’s trueWhat it means for you
Australia’s eSafety compliance update found 7 in 10 kids who had accounts on restricted platforms before the ban still have themA law can remove the sign-up page and barely touch the behavior underneath it
Over 80% of Australian teens ages 10-15 still use social media frequently, almost a year into the banFrequency of use, not account status, is the number that actually matters — and it hasn’t moved much
A peer-reviewed University of Newcastle study published in The BMJ found 85%+ of adolescents under 16 were still on banned platforms three months after the law took effectThis isn’t a slow rollout problem. Circumvention started almost immediately
MIT Technology Review (Oct 16, 2026) documented kids using a sibling’s face for ID or drawing on fake facial hair to beat age-estimation techKids aren’t passively losing access. They’re actively, creatively working around it
France’s own under-15 ban was struck down by its top court in August 2026 on constitutional groundsAustralia isn’t the only country finding out this is harder to pull off than it sounds in a press conference

Read that table twice before you decide what it means for your house. It’s not an argument against caring about this. It’s an argument against outsourcing the caring to a law.

The number that should’ve been the headline

Start with the compliance update itself, because it’s the clearest data point here. Australia’s eSafety Commissioner surveyed parents whose kids had accounts before the December 10, 2025 ban took effect, and nearly 70% said their kid still had a Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, or TikTok account. Not “still finds a way online sometimes.” Still has the account. The thing the law specifically made illegal for a platform to let them keep.

Pair that with the usage number from the same reporting — over 80% of 10-to-15-year-olds still on social media frequently — and you’ve got a law that’s barely dented the behavior it was built to stop. I wrote in September about the study showing age of first exposure matters more than account ownership, and at the time, Australia’s own early tracking backed that up: roughly eight in ten teens were still online three months post-ban. A year later, the number hasn’t meaningfully improved. It’s the same story, just with more months behind it.

The study that should’ve been a warning, not a footnote

The eSafety numbers aren’t an outlier. A peer-reviewed study out of the University of Newcastle, published in The BMJ, followed 408 adolescents ages 12 to 17 before and three months after the ban took effect. More than 85% of participants under 16 were still using the restricted platforms. Most of them were doing it on their own accounts — not borrowed, not fake. Just… still there.

The researchers also measured how kids who did hit a wall got around it. Roughly a fifth used a fake account. About one in ten used a private browser. A meaningful share logged in through someone else’s account entirely. None of that required hacking anything. It required the same low-effort problem-solving a 13-year-old uses to get out of a chore.

Here’s the part that should sting a little: the study’s own authors said it’s “insufficient evidence of any substantive early effects” and noted it could take a decade to know the law’s real impact. A decade. Your kid will be through high school, college, and halfway into a career before anyone can say with confidence whether this policy did what it was built to do.

How they’re actually getting around it

MIT Technology Review’s October 16, 2026 reporting is the part that’ll make you laugh before it makes you worry. Age-estimation tools scan a face and guess whether it belongs to someone over or under the cutoff. Kids figured out the tools fast, and the workarounds are almost sweetly low-tech:

  1. Drawing on fake facial hair. One parent told researchers she caught her son using an eyebrow pencil to sketch a mustache — and the system verified him as 15.
  2. Using a sibling’s or parent’s face. If the camera just needs a face that looks old enough, any face in the house can do the job.
  3. Self-declared age. The most common verification method on several platforms is still just typing in a birthdate. Nobody checks it against anything.
  4. Private browsers and borrowed logins. When a device is flagged, switching browsers or using a friend’s account resets the clock.
  5. Fake accounts built from scratch. Some kids skip the workaround entirely and just build a new identity the platform has no reason to flag.

None of this takes technical skill. It takes a bored afternoon and the motivation every young teenager already has to get back to the thing an adult just took away. The MIT Technology Review piece makes an uncomfortable argument on top of all this: closing these loopholes harder might not help. It could push kids off mainstream, moderated platforms and into corners of the internet with no moderation at all — a worse trade than the one the ban was trying to make.

Australia isn’t the only cautionary tale

Zoom out and the pattern isn’t unique to one country. France’s own under-15 social media ban was supposed to start September 1, 2026, with existing underage accounts getting a four-month wind-down. France’s Constitutional Council struck it down in August, ruling the law placed an excessive burden on freedom of expression and failed to specify how age would actually get verified without requiring every adult to prove their age too.

Two different countries, two different legal systems, two different failure modes — one trying to enforce a ban that kids route around, the other never getting its ban enforced at all. I’ve tracked how differently other institutions are handling this same pressure — schools banning phones, states suing platforms, juries awarding damages — and the pattern holds across all of it. Every lever that isn’t a parent paying attention is slower and leakier than anyone promised it would be.

Why the law was never going to be enough

Step back and the reason isn’t mysterious. A law can block a sign-up page. It can’t block a kid’s motivation to be where their friends are, and it can’t out-design teenagers who have nothing but free time and a reason to care. The mechanism behind what these platforms do to a developing brain doesn’t turn off because a government drew a line at age 16. The scrolling, the dopamine loop, the social pressure of being the one kid not in the group chat — none of that cares what the law says.

I want to be careful here, because this isn’t an argument that the ban was pointless. A law that stops platforms from courting under-16 sign-ups, that forces “reasonable steps” even imperfect ones, that puts companies on notice they’re being watched — that’s worth having on the books. It’s just not a finish line. It never was. The actual finish line was always going to be what happens in your house, on a Tuesday, when nobody from the government is in the room.

That’s the thing I keep coming back to on this topic: you can’t legislate a kid’s judgment into existence. You can only build it, one conversation and one boundary at a time, long before any law ever gets a vote.

What to do this week

Stop treating “there’s a ban” as the plan

If you’ve been coasting on the assumption that a law somewhere handles this, the data says it doesn’t. This is one of the harder conversations in the Middle School section of the field guide, and it doesn’t get easier because a government tried to have it for you.

Ask what’s actually on the phone, not what the account settings say

An account getting flagged or deleted doesn’t mean the behavior stopped. Check for apps reinstalled under a different name, a sibling’s login still saved, a browser that opens straight into a feed.

Talk about why, not just whether

A kid who understands what these feeds are built to do — keep them scrolling, not inform them or connect them — makes better decisions alone than a kid who’s just been told no. The Roblox safety lawsuit I covered is one more data point in a growing pile: these products are built by people whose job is engagement, not your kid’s wellbeing.

Revisit this in three months

Laws, enforcement, and the apps themselves are all still moving. What’s true about a platform’s safety gaps this month may not hold by spring. Make this a recurring check, not a one-time conversation.

The takeaway

A government can ban an app. It can’t ban the reason your kid wants to be on it. That part’s still yours.

This article is part of the Middle School collection.

Browse all Middle School lessons →