Read This Someday

Your Loan Cap Just Pushed You to a Pricier Lender

Grad PLUS loans disappeared on July 1, and the bill for that didn’t vanish with them. It just changed address. The Associated Press reported this week that grad students who used to walk into the federal program for whatever their program cost are now walking straight into private lenders instead. Sallie Mae’s graduate loan originations are up 119% year over year. SoFi just had the biggest student-loan quarter in its history. Neither company caused this. Congress did. They’re just the ones answering the phone.

The short version

What’s trueWhat it means for you
Grad PLUS loans ended for new borrowers on July 1, 2026, replaced by federal caps of $100,000 for most graduate programs and $200,000 for professional degrees, inside a $257,500 lifetime limit across all federal borrowing (One Big Beautiful Bill Act)If your program costs more than your cap, the gap doesn’t close itself. It becomes somebody’s loan — probably not the government’s
Sallie Mae’s graduate loan originations jumped 119% year-over-year in Q3 2026, part of $3.4 billion in total private education lending (AP, Nov. 6, 2026)The lender that used to be a backup plan is now where a lot of grad students are landing by default
SoFi originated $2.9 billion in student loans in Q3 2026 — up 96% from a year earlier and the largest quarter in the company’s history (SoFi Q3 2026 earnings release)This isn’t one lender having a good quarter. It’s an industry catching the overflow from a federal program that just got smaller
Average private rates in early November 2026: 8.75% fixed over 10 years, 10.05% variable over 5 years (Forbes Advisor), versus 8.07% on the federal grad loan the caps just capped (Department of Education)Private isn’t catastrophically more expensive than federal. It’s a few points worse — and it comes stripped of the safety net
Private loans skip income-driven repayment, Public Service Loan Forgiveness eligibility, and guaranteed death or disability discharge (CFPB)The rate is the smaller problem. The missing protections are the one that actually bites you later

What actually changed when Grad PLUS disappeared

I covered the mechanics of this back in October: the Grad PLUS elimination replaced unlimited federal borrowing for grad school with hard numbers. $20,500 a year, $100,000 total, for most master’s programs. $50,000 a year up to $200,000 for law, medicine, and other professional degrees. A $257,500 lifetime ceiling sits on top of all of it, counting every dollar you’ve ever borrowed, undergrad included.

That earlier post was about the good news hiding inside the bad news: schools started cutting tuition because they could no longer assume the federal government would cover whatever number they wrote down. This post is about the part that tuition cuts don’t fix. A 35% discount doesn’t help the student whose program still costs more than the new ceiling allows. For that student, the gap didn’t close. It just went looking for a new lender.

That’s the student the AP found. A physician assistant program in New York City, where the cost per year runs well past what the new federal limit covers. Steven Freedman, associate dean of admissions at the University of Kansas School of Law, put the shift more bluntly than most officials would: “Now, frankly, private banks get to choose who goes to law school.” The cap didn’t make grad school cheaper for everyone. It made the federal government a smaller piece of a bill that, for a lot of programs, never got smaller itself.

Some schools are responding faster than others. Lewis & Clark College’s graduate school of education and counseling, in Portland, started offering a new need-based scholarship this fall specifically because its financial aid office watched more students turn to private loans once the caps hit. That’s a school reading the same numbers you’re reading and deciding to absorb part of the gap instead of letting every student eat it alone. Not every school is doing that yet. Ask yours directly if it is.

The surge in private lending, by the numbers

Sallie Mae controls more than half the private student loan market, which is exactly why its earnings are the cleanest read on where the displaced borrowing went. Graduate loan originations rose 119% year-over-year in the third quarter of 2026, inside $3.4 billion in total private education lending, itself up 15% from a year earlier. That’s not a company having an unusually good quarter. That’s a company absorbing demand that used to have a federal home.

SoFi’s numbers tell the same story from a different angle. $2.9 billion in student loan originations in Q3 2026, up 96% from a year before, and the largest quarter the company has ever posted. I wrote in September about a Loyola Marymount law student who hit the $257,500 lifetime cap mid-degree with no federal options left. She wasn’t a one-off. She was early.

I’ll say the quiet part plainly: a 96% jump and a 119% jump in the same quarter, at two different companies, aren’t a coincidence of good marketing. They’re a policy working exactly as designed — just not necessarily working out for the people on the other end of it. The administration’s own argument for the caps is that unlimited federal borrowing let schools charge whatever they wanted, and that’s not a crazy argument. Tuition at some schools really is coming down because of it. But a policy can be right about the cause and still leave the current borrower holding the difference. Both of those things are true at once, and most of the coverage this week only wants to tell you one of them.

What private student loan interest rates look like right now

Here’s where I want to correct a number before it gets repeated wrong. Private loan rates are higher than federal rates right now, but they’re not catastrophically higher. As of early November 2026, Credible’s data (via Forbes Advisor) puts the average 10-year fixed private rate at 8.75% and the average 5-year variable rate at 10.05%. The federal direct unsubsidized loan for grad students this year runs 8.07%. The old Direct PLUS rate, before Grad PLUS disappeared, was 9.07%.

Run the comparison honestly and the private fixed rate is maybe three-quarters of a point worse than what you’d have paid under the federal program that just ended. The variable rate is worse than that, and it can climb further — rates have already moved up half a point since late October. That’s real money over ten years. It’s also not the headline.

The headline is what the rate doesn’t come with.

What protections do you lose by borrowing privately?

Three things, specifically, and all three matter more than the rate:

  1. Income-driven repayment. Federal loans let you tie your monthly payment to what you actually earn. Private loans don’t. You owe the fixed payment whether this is your best year or your worst one.
  2. Public Service Loan Forgiveness eligibility. If you’re borrowing to become a nurse, teacher, or public defender and were counting on PSLF to erase what’s left after ten years of qualifying payments, a private loan doesn’t count toward that clock. It never will.
  3. Death and disability discharge. Every federal student loan gets discharged if you die or become permanently disabled. Private lenders aren’t required to offer this. Roughly half do, voluntarily, buried in the fine print. Half don’t.

I know a lower sticker shock feels like the win when you’re staring at two offers. Losing PSLF eligibility doesn’t feel like anything at all — until the year you actually needed it, and by then the loan’s already five years old.

What to do before you hit the cap

Six things, in the order they actually matter if you’re applying to grad school or already enrolled.

  1. Calculate your real federal gap now, not at enrollment. Program cost minus your federal cap is the number you need to close, and it’s better to know it in the spring than discover it when tuition’s due.
  2. Shop more than one private lender. Rates on the same loan can swing more than two points based on your credit and whether you have a cosigner. Your credit score is already doing more work than you think in this exact decision.
  3. Ask every private lender, in writing, what happens if you die or become disabled. Don’t assume. Half of them have no discharge provision at all, and the fine print is where that fact lives.
  4. Exhaust scholarships, assistantships, and employer tuition benefits before you sign anything private. Whether the degree is worth the debt at all depends partly on how much of the gap you can close without borrowing it.
  5. If you must go private, take the fixed rate over the variable one. 8.75% today is a number you can plan around. 10.05% today is a number that can still move on you.
  6. If your field depends on PSLF, protect that eligibility like it’s the asset it actually is. Keep as much of your borrowing federal as the caps allow, even if a private loan would shave a point off your rate. The broader loan overhaul already asks enough of your repayment plan without voluntarily giving up the one benefit built to help you.

The takeaway

A federal loan cap doesn’t make the cost of your degree smaller. It just decides who’s allowed to lend you the rest — and the lender who answers that call isn’t required to offer you a single one of the protections the government was.

This article is part of the Money & Finances collection.

Browse all Money & Finances lessons →